Credit: Von Balanon for Fresnoland

What's at stake:

This month's Fresno election results were no fluke.

A new generation of council campaigns are reaching regular people like never before.

Two weeks ago, die-hards of Fresno politics got their shock of the decade: the Fresno City Council abandoned its years-long quest to approve SEDA, Mayor Jerry Dyer’s signature $4 billion mega-project. Developers at the meeting were livid that the plan to build a new Clovis on the outskirts of southeast Fresno failed, and many longtime observers said they had never seen the council say no to a sprawl project that big and that juicy. After the vote, reporters swarmed the mayor and council members to ask what had changed their minds. Dyer and Councilmember Miguel Arias both pointed to one thing: the election results.

Only the hour before the vote, it became clear that the three council candidates who had campaigned against SEDA would each win their races. City Hall insiders let the project go because they worried that any lame-duck approval would be overturned in January. The about-face came during a historic week in politics across the country. Mississippi elected its first Black U.S. senator since the end of Reconstruction and the rise of Jim Crow. Why couldn’t Fresno get an anti-sprawl majority on its city council?

The result was no fluke, a Fresnoland analysis shows. The council’s deference to its incoming members on SEDA was the clearest sign yet of a possible shift in who calls the shots in Fresno. The city’s political establishment has been losing its grip on the council for two years, data shows. Since 2024, the council candidate with more money from the establishment has lost five of the last six races, including two of the three runoffs this month.

That finding comes from a database Fresnoland built this election season: roughly 20,000 contributions to Fresno-area city and county candidates since 2012, drawn from city and county campaign disclosure forms, including scanned paper filings. It brings Fresno’s campaign money together in one place for the first time and traces it across 14 years.

The database let Fresnoland track patterns, define the establishment and test how its candidates fared at the ballot box. It shows that this year’s national populist surge did not replace local politics. Instead, it amplified a movement that was already building in Fresno: more ordinary people are paying for Fresno’s campaigns than ever before.

This election was a renaissance for donors who had not given to a local campaign in years. At least 1,045 people who had not given to a Fresno council or mayoral campaign in the previous six years gave to council candidates this year, together over $700,000. Both figures are the highest since at least 2012, the earliest year in the dataset, and nearly double the previous highs.

At the same time, developer money going to city council candidates fell this year to its lowest point in the data. Developers supplied 2.4% of the money council candidates raised this year. In every other election since 2012, the figure was between 9% and 18%.

That sets the stage for a truly historic council session. Can the new members deliver for the residents who paid for their campaigns, keeping them mobilized with progress on bread-and-butter issues like affordability and investment in the city’s core? If they do, the bloom of small donors may last.

The data also holds a cautionary tale. The last time Fresno saw a surge like this, in 2018, it didn’t last. Two years later, the number of first-time donors to council candidates had fallen by two-thirds, and the establishment supplied more than half of all the money council candidates raised, its highest share in 14 years. The insurgents of 2018 ran for re-election on establishment money. If the incoming council follows that path, it could end up where the outgoing one did: dark money sloshing around and members entertaining $4 billion plans for $500,000 homes, all in the name of housing affordability and the city’s financial health.

City establishment failed to beat Singh

The race that pitted these two ways of paying for a council seat most clearly against each other was in west and central Fresno’s District 1.

Rob Fuentes, a former federal prosecutor who handled cases for ICE, and whom critics say has flouted pay-to-play laws, ran on the city’s establishment money. His largest donors were the institutions that have long bankrolled Fresno politics: the police and fire unions, the city employees’ association and a developer who ranks among the city’s biggest political givers.

Half the money Fuentes raised, 51%, came from that core of donors, a larger share than any other council candidate on the ballot. The firefighters gave him more than $10,000. The police officers’ association and the city employees’ association gave more than $10,000 each. Developer Richard Spencer and his wife, Karen, gave more than $20,000 between them across the primary and runoff.

His opponent, and now Councilmember-elect Naindeep Singh, a Central Unified trustee, set a modern record for donations from people outside the city’s establishment.

Individuals gave Singh more than $260,000, more than any council candidate has raised from individuals since at least 2012. The next highest, Annalisa Perea in 2022, raised about $190,000. At least 228 of Singh’s donors had never before given to a Fresno council or mayoral campaign, more first-timers than any council campaign has drawn since at least 2018. Only 5% of Singh’s money came from Fresno’s establishment core.

Singh won, 54.8% to 45.2%.

The stark difference between the two candidates made the race a litmus test for the city’s establishment: Do the donors who have paid for Fresno politics still get to pick its winners?

Lately, the answer has been no.

Fresno’s developers are in a slump

From its database, Fresnoland identified the city’s donor establishment: this year, about 120 businesses, developers, unions, political committees and individual donors who give to the same Fresno council campaigns again and again. It is less a coordinated bloc than a habit, the same checks written to campaign after campaign. For generations of local politicians, these checks were the surest way to win.

For years, Fresno’s establishment could all but pick its candidate and pay to put them there. In 2012, 2014 and 2016, the council candidate who raised the most money from the establishment before election day won all seven contested races. From 2018 through March 2024, that candidate won seven of 10.

Since November 2024, that candidate has lost five of six. And the establishment’s lone victory — Arambula — can hardly be chalked up as a W.

The losing streak is only part of the shift. The establishment not only has been losing to upstarts and outsiders — it has also changed shape.

For the last decade, the establishment stood on two legs: developers who need the council to rezone fringe-area land for tract homes and mini-malls, and the predominantly public-sector unions whose wages and benefits the council approves. Now one of those legs is giving out.

Developers supplied around 15% in every election from 2012 through 2024, records show. But this year they slumped to just 2.4%. In raw dollar amounts, the picture looks even worse: their giving to council candidates fell by more than 80%, from about $254,000 by election day in 2022 to about $44,000 this year.

What’s left is a smaller establishment, run mostly by labor.

This year, unions supplied 56% of the establishment’s council money, up from 37% in 2022. Developers, real estate firms and builders together supplied 18% of it, down from 33% in 2024.

In all, the establishment gave council candidates less than two-thirds of what it gave in 2022, leaving a quarter-million-dollar hole in Fresno’s political machine.

The money didn’t disappear. Much of it went to the county.

Take for example Fresno City Councilmember Mike Karbassi. He took about $100,000 from developers, real estate firms and builders in his bid to replace Brian Pacheco for the District 1 seat on the Board of Supervisors. 

Karbassi’s total is more than half of what every other Fresno council candidate received from developers combined over the same period, about $170,000. Companies tied to Shiralian Enterprises, which runs truck stops and gas stations, gave him nearly $40,000 more.

Karbassi raised about $410,000, and an independent committee called Family Businesses & Public Safety for Mike Karbassi spent about $170,000 more on his behalf. The county’s establishment supplied 22% of his money, and members of the city’s establishment who aren’t also part of the county’s supplied another 18%. His opponent, Maria Pacheco, raised about $220,000, with 3% from the county’s establishment and 1% from the city’s. 

But Pacheco had outside help in the runoff: two groups, led by SEIU Local 2015, reported spending over $400,000 to support her or attack Karbassi.

The loss means Karbassi keeps his Fresno City Council District 2 seat, and there will be no special election for it. On the county board, more could change: Supervisor Nathan Magsig won his race for the 12th State Senate District, 59.9% to 40.1%. His supervisor seat is now open.

Outraised nearly 2 to 1, Martinez-Lott still comes out on top

The candidates who rose up in the city’s breach came to define themselves partly by opposing SEDA, an establishment project in its purest form, and one Fresno’s political machine has spent years trying to get approved. Singh helped lead Central Unified’s first-of-its-kind vote to oppose the project. Ariana Martinez Lott, running in District 7, and Joaquin Arambula, running in District 3, showed up at SEDA’s packed, record-breaking hearings at City Hall time and time again over the last year.

They appear to have turned the populist energy of SEDA’s opposition into campaigns powered by individual donors. Singh drew 244 individual donors and Arambula 236, more than any council campaign since at least 2012. Martinez Lott drew 212.

District 7 was a closer version of the Fuentes-Singh race. Martinez Lott’s opponent, Nav Gurm, an attorney endorsed by Dyer and Councilmember Tyler Maxwell, was the establishment’s candidate there, though by a smaller margin.

Just over a quarter of Gurm’s money, 26%, came from the establishment, well above the 14% for Martinez Lott. The firefighters gave Gurm more than $10,000, and the city employees’ association gave more than $10,000, the same amount it gave Martinez Lott.

When Gurm celebrated making the runoff in June, at a bar in the Tower District, the room was filled with a who’s who of the establishment and its top staffers. Dyer was there, along with Maxwell, a possible 2028 mayoral candidate. So were Council President Nelson Esparza and City Manager Georgeanne White, Dyer’s top staffer and SEDA guru.

Gurm also took $5,900 from the Central Valley Council PAC, whose operator is Alex Tavlian, the political consultant of choice for Fresno’s establishment. Its largest funder is an Atlanta company, SPH Placements, which gave more than $200,000, Fresnoland reported. Its other funders include Mid-Valley Disposal, which holds the city’s south-side commercial trash franchise; Granville Homes, the company of Darius Assemi, another major developer and a SEDA backer; and industrial developer Peter Stravinski.

Gurm raised nearly twice as much as Martinez Lott, about $330,000 to $170,000. Outside groups, led by the California Apartment Association’s committee, reported spending more than $40,000 on independent expenditures naming him. Martinez Lott won anyway, 57.9% to 42.1%.

What happened to the last insurgents?

District 3 shows the establishment’s other survival instinct: hedging.

There, the establishment had no clear favorite. Arambula and Keshia Thomas, a Fresno Unified trustee who beat Fuentes for her school board seat in 2018, drew nearly identical shares of their money from the establishment core, about 26% each. Because Arambula raised more, he took more of the establishment’s dollars, about $50,000 to Thomas’s $30,000.

But Arambula also did what Singh did. He drew 236 individual donors to Thomas’s 128, and raised nearly $100,000 from individuals to her $30,000.

Both candidates said they opposed SEDA, but Thomas had a mixed record on it. In February, she was one of four Fresno Unified trustees who voted to indefinitely table the district’s resolution opposing the project, a day after Dyer texted trustees asking the district not to take a position against it. She voted for the resolution when it passed in May. Unlike Arambula, Thomas did not attend the raucous SEDA hearings.

Arambula won, 53.9% to 46.2%.

Come January, Singh, Martinez Lott and Brandon Vang will hold seats they won against the establishment’s pick. Councilmembers Maxwell, Karbassi and Nick Richardson have the council’s closest ties to establishment money. Arambula sits in between: well connected enough to draw more establishment money than his opponent, and popular enough to draw more individual donors than all but one council campaign in 14 years.

Which way will he go? Fresno has watched outsiders face that choice before.

In 2018, the establishment’s pick lost two council races. Arias won District 3, the seat Arambula now takes over. In District 7, Esparza, backed by labor, beat Brian Whelan, the developers’ candidate, who raised more than $400,000, the most of any council candidate that year. Two years later, Maxwell beat the establishment’s pick in District 4. The 2018 races were also significant for setting the record for grassroots fundraising that stood until this year: Genoveva “Veva” Islas, a public-health advocate who is now president of the Fresno Unified school board, drew 229 individual donors in District 7. She finished third. (Islas is done, however, in her latest race this year)

The surge faded. By 2020, the number of first-time donors to council candidates had fallen from 642 to 203.

And all three upsets became establishment candidates. Esparza’s 2022 re-election set the modern record for money raised from the establishment, more than $210,000. Maxwell’s unopposed 2024 re-election drew 69% of its money from the establishment core, a larger share than any council campaign since 2018. As the establishment money grew, their circles of individual donors shrank: Esparza went from 140 individual donors to 101, and Arias from 90 to 79.

Arias and Esparza leave the council in January, replaced by Arambula and Martinez Lott. Esparza, who beat the developers’ candidate in 2018, was in the room in June when Gurm, his former staffer and the establishment’s choice to succeed him, celebrated making the runoff.

The two council members who have already served since the losing streak began show both paths.

Richardson started the streak in 2024. A young Marine Corps reservist with little political experience, he was deployed overseas in the middle of his District 6 campaign. His opponent, Roger Bonakdar, a lawyer, ran the way establishment candidates always had, with the police union, the firefighters and Shiralian Enterprises among his top donors. He outraised Richardson about 8 to 1, roughly $460,000 to $60,000, and spent nearly nine of every 10 dollars with Park West Associates, political operative Alex Tavlian’s firm. The establishment supplied 33% of Bonakdar’s money and 4.5% of Richardson’s. Richardson won by 990 votes.

Now Richardson appears to be following Maxwell, whom he grew up with, according to Richardson. Of the money Richardson has raised for his 2028 re-election so far, 76% has come from establishment donors, among them River Park Properties, a partnership of Ed Kashian, the developer who has shaped Fresno more than any other. Kashian’s Fancher Creek needs rooftops to become a regional center the size of River Park, and SEDA would have supplied them.

Vang took the other path. In a March 2025 special election on SEDA’s frontier in southeast Fresno, a race Dyer had told developers would set the terms of the SEDA debate, he faced Elizabeth Jonasson Rosas, a Fresno Unified trustee and former Westlands Water District executive who was running to succeed her husband, Luis Chavez, after he left the seat for the Board of Supervisors. The establishment supplied 53% of her money. Vang, a father of five born in Laos during the Vietnam War and a former Sanger Unified trustee, raised about $110,000, 98% of it from individuals and none of it from the establishment.

In the race’s final weeks, a committee whose main funder, Fresnoland later found, shares a business address with Tavlian’s companies sent mailers accusing Vang of statutory rape, citing a 1993 child-support case over the birth of his first child. It drew a similar controversy to Singh’s now bogus arrest by the Fresno Police Department last month. In Vang’s case, the mother, then 15, is May Lee, his wife of more than 30 years. Vang was never charged. Tavlian, later listed as the committee’s treasurer, paid its $1,000 fine with a check from Park West; he has said Park West had no role in producing the mailer.

Vang won in the 2025 special election with 50.19% of the vote, eight votes more than he needed to avoid a runoff. This June he won a full term outright over Danielle Parra, who drew 34% of her money from the establishment core, while Vang drew 16% of his campaign cash from the establishment.

Right after the SEDA vote, Vang was able to take a deep breath. Smiling ear-to-ear, SEDA was behind him. And Singh, a fellow traveler of slanderous mailers, was about to take a seat next to him. 

Vang said he felt relieved that he would be joined by true outsiders.

“I’ve been here two years, but the reality is I’m part of that group.”

HOW WE DID IT

Fresnoland collected 20, 254 contributions to candidates for Fresno City Council and mayor, Fresno County supervisor and other local offices, from 2012 through Nov. 3, 2026. They come from campaign disclosure forms (Forms 460 and 497) filed with the City of Fresno and Fresno County, including paper filings that we scanned and transcribed.

We defined the “establishment core” as donors who repeatedly give to Fresno council campaigns across election cycles. In 2026, the core had about 120 members: businesses, developers, unions, political committees and individuals. Each race was measured against the core in place at the time. For 2012 and 2014, before the electronic record is complete enough to build a core, we used the 2016 core. A race’s “establishment pick” is the candidate who raised more money from the core before the final election. Shares exclude candidates’ own money and loans.

A “first-time” donor is an individual who had not given to a Fresno council or mayoral committee in the previous six years. Donors were matched across filings by name and address. Donor categories, such as developer or union, were assigned by Fresnoland.

Independent expenditures, money spent by outside groups rather than given to a campaign, are not counted in the candidates’ totals or shares. They are reported separately where noted.

Comparisons with past elections use the same point in each cycle: election day. For 2026, gifts under $1,000 made from Oct. 18 through Nov. 3 are not yet itemized; they will appear on reports due Jan. 31, 2027, so 2026 counts of individual and first-time donors are minimums. Nov. 3 results are the Fresno County preliminary count of Nov. 16 and are not yet certified.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Gregory Weaver is a staff writer for Fresnoland who covers the environment, air quality, and development.