Chuck Riojas, answering questions about project labor agreements from the Fresno County Board of Supervisors. Pablo Orihuela | Fresnoland

What's at stake?

The Fresno County Board of Supervisors will wait until next year to discuss what developments could be part of project labor agreement.

The board also discussed the state's child welfare report, added some help to its public records office, and said farewell to most of its supervisors before they leave for the state legislature.

The Fresno County Board of Supervisors unanimously pushed a vote on a project labor agreement for a proposed development to 2027, citing a desire to have a clearer view of the countyโ€™s development timeline and to allow the incoming board members to have a say on the matter.

The labor agreement would have been for the proposed 45,000-square-foot office building shared by the countyโ€™s agricultural commissioner and the University of California. The offices would have served as an extension of the countyโ€™s Juvenile Justice Center.

A PLA is a document that works as a guiding framework for hiring and business practices for contractors. Tuesdayโ€™s discussion was not for a countywide PLA, rather just for the office project. 

The project has a preliminary cost of $32 million, but that cost could balloon as the county makes its way toward ground-breaking. The proposed office is part of a lengthy development wishlist for the county, which includes relocating sheriffโ€™s deputies and board of supervisors to new buildings, and renovating or demolishing old properties.

However, though the county has about $35 million set aside for the office building, supervisors said that they may need to “cannibalize” other projects on their development pipeline to make sure priority projects can make their deadline. The office building is not the highest priority for the county. 

Supervisor Nathan Magisig said Tuesday that his hesitation with approving the county to work toward a PLA stemmed fromโ€œthe current environment we’re in budgetarily.โ€ 

โ€œI don’t know that we are ready to move forward unless county staff comes forward and shares with me that they’ve got plans designed,โ€ Magsig said, โ€œand this is in the queue for something that we’re going to be able to bid in the next six to eight months.โ€

A countywide PLA has been a desire among some local contractors for quite some time. However, other builders have fiercely opposed establishing these agreements, arguing that they are exclusionary toward non-union workers and serve as unnecessary red tape to getting projects done in a cheap and quick manner.

Chuck Riojas, executive director of the Fresno-Madera Building Trades Council, has helped pass PLAs for the local projects and governments in the past.

Riojas said at Tuesdayโ€™s county meeting that he pursues the establishment of PLAs because they provide young workers access to apprenticeships and, hopefully, higher paying jobs. He added that his PLAs donโ€™t exclude non-union workers.

โ€œI refuse to negotiate those,โ€ Riojas said. โ€œThey’ll never be part of my agenda. I believe there is a spot for both union and non union contractors in our arena.โ€

The board ultimately passed on the item until next year, but some builders felt the county choosing to put the item on the agenda in the first place was a slight against them and their interests.

Faye Yassini, government affairs director for the Associated Builders and Contractorsโ€™ Northern California chapter, was among the about half a dozen speakers on Tuesday who thanked the board for tabling the item. Yassini argued that PLAs actually increase costs, a common refrain among the policyโ€™s opponents.

After the meeting, Riojas told Fresnoland that โ€œyou can find 100 papers online that are pro-PLA, and 100 papers that are anti-PLA,โ€ arguing that he was not surprised to hear opposition to Tuesdayโ€™s proposal. 

โ€œBut happy to engage as always,โ€ Riojas said. โ€œYou win some, you lose some.โ€

Riojas was part of the effort to get the City of Fresno to pass a citywide PLA. The PLA was granted an extension at last weekโ€™s Fresno City Council meeting.

Bredefeld, Board continue to put pressure on DSS leadership

A day after unveiling a state report highlighting โ€œserious deficienciesโ€ in the countyโ€™s department of social services, the board of supervisors directed special attention to department head Sanja Bugay, promising accountability.

โ€œI expect you to be held accountable as to whether changes to your department happened,โ€ said board chair Garry Bredefeld to Bugay.

Bredefeld was among a trio of county leaders on Monday that said the stateโ€™s report, which he called โ€œan abominationโ€ on the countyโ€™s record, brings the potential for reorganization within the department, though they did not specify what that would look like when asked by the media.

Bugay referred Fresnoland questions to the countyโ€™s spokesperson. 

Bredefeld, with support of the board, directed Bugay to report to the board monthly to provide updates on the departmentโ€™s progress in working to meet the stateโ€™s standards and best practices for child welfare.

โ€œI’m getting a lot of contacts since yesterday about all kinds of problems that people have experienced with your department,โ€ Bredefeld later added, โ€œand this is unacceptable, and we’re going to fix it one way or the other. โ€

Supervisor Luis Chavez also said that Bugay had privately lobbied to dissolve the Foster Care Oversight Committee. However, as the stateโ€™s report seemingly corroborated the complaints of multiple critics, including some members of the committee, Chavez said that wouldn’t be happening. 

โ€œWhat I will tell you is that not only will it not be dissolved, it’s actually going to get beefed up more,โ€ Chavez said. 

County hires more people to handle PRAs

The board of supervisors approved the hiring of a paralegal to help properly and efficiently address what they say are an increasing number of public records requests the county is receiving. 

The position is expected to open up later this month. It would increase the total number of paralegals in the county counsel department, part of the group that handles records requests, to 44. 

Board says goodbye to supervisors-turned-newly-elected-state-legislators

Tuesdayโ€™s meeting also saw the board bid adieu to Supervisors Magsig and Brian Pacheco, both of whom will be serving in the state legislature next year after winning their election bids in November. 

Though there is one more meeting in the boardโ€™s 2027 calendar, it comes one day after new state legislators are sworn in. On that same day, Dec. 7, bills get introduced and the stateโ€™s get to work.

Magsig and Pacheco will join a legislature that also begins working with Xavier Becerra, the newly elected Democrat Governor. Among Becerraโ€™s first orders of action, will be unveiling his first proposed budget for the next fiscal year. The budget proposal is expected to be published on Jan.10. 

โ† Back

Thank you for your response. โœจ