Fresno City Councilmember Miguel Arias, left, and Fresno City Attorney Andrew Janz, right, wagged fingers at each other on Thursday in the wake of the high-profile arrest and swift exoneration of a council candidate in one of the most contentious races on the local ballot. Fresnoland composite

What's at stake?

Tuesday marked the second public clash between Councilmember Migeul Arias and City Attorney Andrew Janz.

Outgoing Fresno City Councilmember Miguel Arias called for “accountability” for “those responsible for the conduct that exposed the City to liability” in connection with a recently announced $1.2 million settlement with a whistleblower who faced retaliation within the Fresno City Attorney’s Office.

Arias released a formal statement Tuesday that, while not mentioning the city attorney’s office or its department head, Andrew Janz, by name, slammed the city’s settlement saying “it failed to address the underlying conduct that made this settlement necessary.”

“When this matter came before the City Council,” Arias said, “I voted against the settlement because it failed to appropriately hold accountable those responsible for the conduct that exposed the City to liability.”

“The City Attorney’s Office policy is to not comment on personnel issues and settlements,” said city attorney spokesperson Marcelino Valdez. “It is unfortunate that Councilmember Arias continues to expose the City to liability by not following the same policy.”

Janz has not commented on the matter publicly.

The Fresno City Council issued a lengthy unsigned statement after business hours on Friday, saying that, despite the hefty payout, City Hall continues to dispute that Janz violated any laws.

The outgoing employee, Tina Griffin, who worked at the city attorney’s office for 20 years before her dispute with Janz, issued a statement as part of the city’s news release on the settlement.

“The investigation conducted by the independent investigator substantiated my allegations of the facts that occurred after I gave my legal opinion and found that my legal opinion contributed to Mr. Janz’s actions towards me,” Griffin said in the statement.

According to city records and statements released Friday night, the confrontation between Griffin and Janz sparked in mid-December last year when Griffin provided a legal analysis of a proposed change to the city’s Transparency Act that questioned whether Janz had a conflict of interest and suggested that Janz should not have signed off on the change, which she concluded could be illegal.

City records show the council on Dec. 18, one day before Griffin filed her complaint, tabled discussion around a proposed change to the city’s transparency act related to reporting how much top city leaders — including Janz — get paid.

Arias thanked Griffin and praised her for her “professionalism, integrity, and commitment to public service that our community deserves.” 

“No public employee should face retaliation for following the law and doing what is right,” Arias said.

And while the City Council appeared to have little appetite for the kind of discipline Arias described, the outgoing councilmember urged the incoming council to take a harder line.

“I hope the next City Council demonstrates the leadership and courage to demand accountability, protect public employees, and ensure Fresno taxpayers are not forced to pay for the conduct of individuals who escape responsibility,” Arias said. “The people of Fresno deserve better, and so do the dedicated public servants who work on their behalf.”

And while Arias didn’t mention Janz by name Tuesday, his statement marks at least the second public clash between Arias and Janz in recent weeks.

Arias and Janz called for dueling investigations into each other in connection with the false arrest last month of councilmember-elect Naindeep Singh.Then, last week, the council said Janz had been cleared of any wrongdoing and, at the same time, Janz dropped his complaint against Arias.

Fresnoland obtained details of the settlement after filing a Public Record Act request in June.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨